Usability Vs SEO
This article is an investigation into whether search engine optimisation and usability are compatible, enabling a user to find a website in a search engine, and then find what they’re looking for once they’ve found it.
Usability and search engine optimisation are both of fundamental importance when developing websites on for the Internet. SEO should be given precedence in the design of a website to improve the chances of users actually finding the site in the first place. Likewise, usability should be of high priority so that users aren’t put off using the site within seconds of finding it.
When optimising a website by maximizing keywords, it is essential not to disrupt the quality of content on the page being optimised. There is no point in spending time and money on directing traffic to your site if the user will back straight out. If you’re at all interested in repeat traffic, usability has to come first. (Peter V, 352media.com: 2007)
The result of poor quality text in a keyword-optimised website is a page that reads like a search engine result page and not one that’s content is centred towards the users’ interests. It should be the case, should it not, that search engines reflect the content of the pages they index, not the other way round? Writing page content that engages the user and speaks their language should not be borne out of a need to fit within Google’s requirements but rather a need to fit the users’ requirements. (J Gibbard, smorgasbord-design.blogspot.com: 2005)
However it is possible to use search engine optimisation to enhance the usability of a website without comprehensive UCD testing. Using descriptive links indicates to the user they are heading in the right direction, emphasizing words with bold text and headers highlights important elements of a website’s content whilst encouraging scanning. Inevitably, user-centred sites with consistent navigation, simple layouts and correct arrangement of keywords are more likely to attract links from elsewhere.
In a recent keynote speech in Barcelona, usability expert Jakob Nielsen predicted that simplification and resolution of basic problems is the key to a positive user experience. Nielsen underlined this point by demonstrating the changes Google has made to its search engine results pages over time, reducing the level of content, removing a left hand column and continuing to improve basic user experience elements such as page load times - from 0.23 seconds in 1999 to 0.08 seconds in 2007. (Jakob Nielsen, bigmouthmedia.com: 2007) With Web 2.0 technologies such as blogs, discussion boards and RSS now in the web design framework, all of which intend to encourage simplification of web processes and user-centred input, there’s scope for significant improvements for all involved.
To evaluate, it appears that SEO is still at a very early stage in website development and the likeliness of gaining a high search engine ranking is still largely determined by incoming links and brand awareness. User centred design however is a very established practice and only when SEO can be incorporated collaboratively into usability’s strict set of guidelines, can a worthwhile partnership be formed.
By Adam Moss



